Tuesday, April 25, 2006

Web Design Methodology

Jakob Neilsen - again. Paper prototyping as a method for avoiding costly changes to code after full implementation - do the design on paper first! (wow - who would have thought of that??)Actually, these are often created on Photoshop etc and printed out. So, the graphics package is giving your user a really attractive, computer generated, visual impression that looks much like the final product might look.

Furthermore, the suggestion is that a prototype - even when it is coded - doesn't have to contain full functionality. So, for example, an asp or php site with dynamic content would not have to be functional - just pretty enough to convince the client.

Many of the observations on this are similar to what was learned/discussed during Warren's module. The waterfall model is slow but reliable, the spiral method is quick and effective but costly and labour intensive etc etc.

OBSERVATION: Based on my own experience I have found that clients, since they often know very little about web design themselves, are quite happy to accept your recommendations, assuming your designs look impressive enough. Therefore, the purpose of prototyping or other design methodology is simply to ensure that you, the designer, end up with the best possible site in the most efficient manner.

4 Comments:

At 12:27 PM, Blogger Ric said...

A danger of prototyping that is highlighted by Diane Wilson, Thyra Rauch, and Joeann Paige of Firelilly Designs, is that too often the prototype reflects the tools available to the designer rather than the needs/wants of the client/user.

This is an EXCELLENT site about web design using spiral and rapid prototyping methodologies.

 
At 12:47 PM, Blogger Allan Maund said...

It's the simple things like using paper that really work. Take a blnk piece of paper and start adding the content. I think using paper would save a lot of time and effort 'pratting' around with web pages, before you know what the client wants!!

 
At 7:17 AM, Blogger Steve said...

I would agree most clients would be impressed with the flashy elements of a web page and not even consider the practical use of the site!

 
At 11:11 AM, Blogger Ric said...

Well, yes and no - actually, most prototyping seems to be carried out not with paper but with graphics packages. These give the richness and colour while allowing for very quick visual mark up of the design. Makes sense to do this before coding - esp if you are going to create a CSS layout for the site.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home